The Alice Network and The Lotus Eaters

Greetings. It feels like I have been away for a long while. I went to Southern California a couple weeks ago to visit my folks and I haven’t posted on the blog since. Things just got away from me this month, but I’m glad to be back and share some of my photos (at left and below) of my time there. California was really lovely, both the desert and the beach. And it must have rubbed off here too because we’ve had great weather in Canada the past couple of weeks, which makes me happy. Fall can be such a gorgeous time of year, and Halloween is supposed to be clear and nice so we will gear up for the trick-or-treaters. 

Meanwhile in recent book news I see that Northern Irish author Anna Burns won the 2018 Man Booker Prize for her novel “Milkman,” which isn’t even available in North America till Dec. 11. Hmm, it seems obscure, but it beat out Richard Powers’s novel “The Overstory” and Rachel Kushner’s “The Mars Room” as well as Esi Edugyan’s novel “Washington Black,” which all made the shortlist among a couple others. That isn’t too shabby competition. Hail to Graywolf Press for its plans to put out the book, which was inspired by the author’s own experience growing up in Northern Ireland. Apparently it’s a dark, experimental novel about a “bookish 18-year-old girl harassed by a paramilitary figure called the milkman during the Troubles in Northern Ireland,” according to The Post’s Ron Charles. What makes the book memorable apparently is the funny, alienated voice of this girl who “refuses to join in the madness,” so writes The Sunday Times. She sounds like a cool character so I’m game to check it out.  Meanwhile I will leave you with a couple reviews of what I finished lately. 

My latest reads were both big sagas — historical fiction that took my mind far away.  First, Kate Quinn’s 2017 novel “The Alice Network,” was my choice for the plane flight to California, which didn’t disappoint as the pages fell easily by the wayside. The book is still amazingly popular as currently there’s 260 holds on 49 copies at my library. But I almost didn’t pick it up because of one critical blog review, but I’m glad Judy’s review at the blog Keep the Wisdom and my sister steered me to do so. It’s an entertaining, sweeping yarn of a story and otherwise I would never have known about this real life spy network that operated during World War I. 

“The Alice Network” is a novel that alternates chapters between two time periods — from 1915 as Eve is recruited to be a spy in France during World War I — and then in 1947 when 19-year-old Charlotte (or Charlie) goes searching for her cousin Rose after WWII. Both stories come together in a fairly swift-paced saga — as a pregnant, yet single Charlie teams up with the curmudgeonly Eve (and Eve’s ex-convict chauffeur Finn), who she thinks might know where her cousin is. Eve though has some baggage and scores of her own to settle, so the journey turns out to be quite a goose chase. And while the link and bad guy between the two timelines was a bit of a stretch for me, I went with it. 

What interested me most was the exploits of the Alice Network, which was based on a real spy operation during World War I and the woman who ran it: French secret agent Louise de Bettignies (also known under the pseudonym as Alice Dubois). Carefully weaved together in the story are a few characters who are based on the real spies and the events that happened to them while others are fictitious. I hadn’t known much about WWI spies or how Resistance fighters were able to intercept German information, so this story intrigued me in that aspect. The courageous feats these women spies pulled off to acquire and pass information along about German military maneuvers — at grave danger to themselves (even to the point of sleeping with the enemy, yikes) — kept me on my toes.

“The Alice Network” is not a dense read nor a powder puff read.  There are some light-ish, romance parts  to it — as well as violent deaths too. It reminded me a bit of Jojo Moyes’s novel “The Girl You Left Behind” and Kristen Hannah’s “The Nightingale” — the same kind of reading perhaps. If you enjoyed those yarns, you’d probably like this. I thought the author did a thorough job of research — as well as having a keen interest and enthusiasm for the history behind it, which she writes about in some notes at the back of the book. For a plane flight and vacation read, it was just the right thing.

Next up, I finished the audiobook of Tatjana Soli’s 2010 debut novel “The Lotus Eaters,” which I was curious about after reading her recent historical novel about George and Libby Custer called “The Removes.”  “The Lotus Eaters” is quite a bit different from that but is also inspired by real people — in this case female war photographers such as Dickey Chapelle and Catherine Leroy who spent time working in Vietnam during the war.  This story is about a female war photographer named Helen Adams who comes to Vietnam in 1965 in the hopes of documenting the war that took her brother’s life. There she gets involved with Sam Darrow, a prize-winning photographer who shows her the ropes. Helen, Sam, and his Vietnamese assistant Linh turn out as the main protagonists of the story, which follows their lives as they become deeper entangled in Vietnam, each other, and their jobs during the war.

Oh my, it’s quite an involved saga. It hit me as being like a “Dr. Zhivago” of the Vietnam War — in that it’s epic and includes a bit of a love triangle. It’s chock-full of the war experience from 1963 to 1975 — from the streets of Saigon, to the missions into the interior, the scorching of villages, the soldiers’ fatalities, to ultimately the final days of the American evacuation and even into the Cambodian killing fields. Most of it is explored through Helen’s eyes and how she becomes taken with the country and the violence and risks that come along with being a war photographer.  The character of Linh too is intriguing, as he’s lost his family and must weigh conflicted loyalties between his heart and his homeland. 

The stories’ themes are plentiful: about war and destruction and its affects on people; the beauty and culture of Vietnam; the adrenaline of photojournalism; trying to find humanity despite the horrors; and about making sense of what happened there. I found quite a bit of the novel’s writing beautiful and a few parts of the action riveting. It wasn’t an easy or light book as it goes off in various tangents and is lengthy — a true saga about Helen’s career and loves and of the U.S. involvement in Vietnam — but I liked much of its truths about the country and the human condition. The author really got under the skin of these characters and I felt by the end they were quite real; they had all gone through so much! Kudos to the author who apparently spent 10 years writing the book, which showed in her depiction of its vivid details. This was my second novel of hers and I’ll be interested to read what she puts out next.

Lastly, I saw the movie “First Man” a few weeks back about the life of astronaut Neil Armstrong and his mission to the moon in 1969. It stars Ryan Gosling and Claire Foy as the Armstrongs. Wow it’s quite a somber and serious movie, which I guess I wasn’t totally expecting. For those who aren’t totally into NASA or space films, you might not find it completely entertaining … though it’s quite interesting but not exactly a light, happy film. This isn’t a Disney version. Both Gosling and Foy are good and seem to play down their star status for the roles. 

It’s a movie with relatively not a lot of dialogue but the cinematography makes it seem quite real.  A few scenes of shaky, spinning aircraft and propulsion, which go on for what feels like too long, might make you feel sick. I certainly was ready for those parts to end, yet I’m glad to have seen the movie. It made me feel how the odds were stacked against the astronauts’ endeavor and yet the moon landing was miraculously persevered and accomplished … despite the old technology back then and all the other hardships they faced. It was enough to make you realize their momentous feat in history. 

That’s all for now.  What about you have you read either of these authors or seen this movie and if so, what did you think? 

This entry was posted in Books, Movies. Bookmark the permalink.

18 Responses to The Alice Network and The Lotus Eaters

  1. Judy Krueger says:

    We had almost identical reactions to The Alice Network (thanks for the shout out!) Truly a worthwhile read despite a few odd or awkward parts. I think Eve was my favorite character.
    I am so glad you liked The Lotus Eaters since I recommended it to you. I can’t remember if you read The Sympathizers, but when I did I kept thinking of Soli’s book.
    I have not seen any current movies. We have been watching older ones on Netflix.
    I have been feeling quite uninspired as regards blogging lately but am trying to keep going. I would miss interacting with you and a few other bloggers whom I feel have become friends of mine though we have never met.
    Happy reading in November!

    • Susan says:

      Thanks Judy, Yes I have read The Sympathizers which is quite a great book. You did recommend The Lotus Eaters to me which I’m glad you did. She wrote some powerful & beautiful sentences in it. I sure hope you continue on with blogging — as your reviews are so essential to people like me. You’re the best around. Maybe take a break if you need it or do less? Whatever is best.

  2. Brian Joseph says:

    The Alice Network sounds interesting. I also know nothing about resistance and spy networks that orginated in the First World War.

    Happy Fall! We have had a lot of rain here in New York, but in between the weather has been nice.

    • Susan says:

      Thanks Brian, glad your fall is good there. Hope the leaves are turning pretty colors. I had no idea about the spies in WWI — I knew some about them in WWII but nothing about them in the first War. This story enlightened me there.

  3. Ti says:

    My son saw First Man in IMAX 3D and was pretty ill afterward.

    The Alice Network sounds interesting enough. My curiosity increased when Reese Witherspoon began to talk about it. I wanna say she is producing the film.

    The weather here in So Cal is still quite warm for November. Ninety or so the past few days with a slight temp drop coming tomorrow. The evenings are so nice though.

    • Susan says:

      Yeah Ti — I see how you’ve moved on into November. It was pretty there in October. I had a nice time on my Cal trip. I can see why your son was ill after First Man in 3D — yikes quite a few spinning scenes that made me a bit ill. 3D would be crazy! I saw where the Alice Network was part of Reese’s book club – it would be cool if she had the movie of it made. I wonder who I would put in the roles, hmm. I’ll think on that.

  4. Ti says:

    BTW… you see how I already moved into November? October. I mean, October.

  5. I don’t keep up with literary prizes so haven’t heard of The Milkman but the descriptions you shared have intrigued me.

    My son wants to see First Man but I’m not into space so I’ll probably skip it. The wobbly scenes would probably make me feel sick.

    • Susan says:

      Hi Kathy, Yeah you probably wouldn’t like First Man — it has quite a few wobbly flight scenes in it. Hmm but your son might enjoy it. I know hardly anything about “Milkman” or Anna Burns but will definitely have a look when it comes out.

  6. Carmen says:

    The Alice Network sounds interesting, but not as much as The Lotus Eaters; that’s more right my alley. I have seen quite a few movies lately, and then re-watch them to fix in the messages, reason why I have been overwhelmed by blogging this month and done very little of it. Like Judy, I’m considering whether I should stop blogging for a while, but then I think that I wouldn’t get my readership back fast enough when I come back, and that stops me. I wouldn’t be disconnected from my feed, just not publishing posts.

    I’ve read great things about First Man. Shaky camerawork makes me dizzy, and that urgency at times is completely moot, but it seems that in this case it was justified to convey the claustrophobia and danger of every training session and trial before the big achievement. I’m really looking forward to this year’s crop of award baits; it seems it is going to be a good bunch.

    • Susan says:

      You’re right about First Man — it really got across the danger of their training sessions but it made me feel a bit ill from all the shaking. We just saw the submarine movie Hunter Killer and it’s a good action flick – might review it for next time. I hope you & Judy will stick with blogging — I enjoy both of your sites & opinions very much, but I can understand taking a break. Everyone needs one sometimes. Cheers.

  7. Fro me, The Alice Network was just a little too light. The unlikely connections got to me, but I can see that it would be great on a trip when you don’t want anything too dense. i want to see First Man. I’m glad to hear you enjoyed it.

    • Susan says:

      Hi Susie: yeah I can understand The Alice Network being a bit too light in parts but you’re right it was good for a plane flight & trip etc. The real history of the network got me a bit. Thx for stopping by.

  8. Rachel says:

    I read The Forgetting Tree by Soli and didn’t care for it. The Lotus Eaters sounds like it might be better.

    • Susan says:

      Hi Rachel: Yeah I think Soli is most known for her very first novel The Lotus Eaters. I found it quite a long, heartfelt saga about the Vietnam War with various components. Not sure I will read The Forgetting Tree but thanks for letting me know your thoughts on it.

  9. You’ve just sold me on The Alice Network, a book I never considered reading before now. The story sounds interesting and the comparison to The Girl You Left Behind and The Nightingale certainly helps 😉 I’d like to make time for The Lotus Eaters, too…

    • Susan says:

      Hi JoAnn: I’m glad I got to The Alice Network which shined a bit of light on this spy operation during WWI. It seemed a similar reading level to those other 2 novels, which I also liked. It was not too dense. The Lotus Eaters was a bit more dense but doable.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.